There is a wide range of standards accepted for female behavior, as well as differences in male attitudes toward the correct treatment of women. Differences arise between tribal and ethnic practices, many of which are alien to the spirit of Islam. Further, the dictates of Islam are subject to diverse interpretation among reformists, traditionalists and ultraconservatives. Debates between these groups can be highly volatile. Westerners who try to urge Pakistani women to assert their rights are likely to simply confuse or frighten the women. Moreover, the men in the community will very likely take such urgings as an insult to their honor and will withdraw their cooperation. Finally, secular practice which allows for more flexible gender roles also comes into conflict with Islamic and ethnic ideologies.
In reality, part of a family's social position and honor depends on the public behavior of its female members. Publicly stepping outside of prescribed societal norms results in moral condemnation and social exclusion thereby placing a burden on both men and women to conform. Under these circumstances, gender roles generally follow defined paths. Male roles reside in family economic welfare, politics, and relationships with outsiders. Within the family they are expected to be disciplinarians and providers for aged parents. Female roles stress motherhood, child rearing and family nurturing. Even among professional career women, family responsibilities remain a top priority.
None dispute the centrality of women in Islamic societies. Respect for women is a notable characteristic and few wish to destroy this esteemed status, nor deny what Islam commands or Pakistani culture values. The debate rages over precisely what constitutes honorable behavior for women in terms of modern realities, especially when women are needed to work outside the home to provide additional income.
No comments:
Post a Comment